Should you use AI (Artificial Intelligence) in fantasy football? Can it actually help you win games—maybe even a championship? Last year, I partnered with Greg Kellogg, an FSWA Hall of Famer, to test this in a head-to-head battle against AI. The only issue? We didn’t keep score. (Pro tip: humans forget, but algorithms don’t.) In 2025, we’re doing it right. We’ll be tracking results weekly, documenting everything, and sharing it with you. By the end of the season, you’ll have the answer to the question every fantasy manager is secretly asking: to AI, or not to AI?

Each week, it’s me, Sir Whittington (Google AI’s fancy alter ego), and KROG squaring off. We’ll each be saddled with three random players — because let’s be honest, the biggest fantasy headaches usually come down to your flex spot.

Here’s how it works:

• One WR or RB ranked outside the top 24

• One TE ranked outside the top 12

• Our mission: pick the guy who can beat his projection and make us look smart.

Your mission: figure out if you should trust me, or the algorithm that also recommends you buy socks after shopping for lawn chairs.

Oh, and here’s the twist — the “winner” isn’t the one who scores the most points. Nope. The player with the most points is actually the loser. We’re tallying it week by week to see who gets crowned by the end of the season.

Week 3 Recap

Here are the NFL players from last week and their fantasy finishes.

RB Tyler Allgeier finished RB67

WR D.J. Moore finished WR29

TE Jake Tonges, finished TE36

Big ups to Rick Brusuelas! He was perfect in his picks last week. As for me and the machines, here are our yearly totals so far.

Sir Whittington’s 8 points

KROG’S 10 points

Tipp 10 points

Let’s not talk about it any further and move on to Week 4. The machines are going down!

Sir Whittington Response:

Week 4 is upon us, and fantasy managers are squinting at their lineups like tourists trying to read a tube map upside down. Some of the early-season stars are twinkling faintly, while others have fallen faster than a teabag in a boiling kettle. Let’s have a peek at three players who could either rescue your squad or make you question your life choices.

T.J. Hockenson looked like a man with a purpose in Week 3, hauling in 5 catches for 49 yards and a touchdown. That’s right, the Vikings’ tight end finally remembered he’s supposed to catch the football. With a matchup against Pittsburgh—who seem to think tight ends are mythical creatures—Hockenson’s targets should keep piling up. In Week 3, he commanded a 25% target share and a 30% first-read share, which is fancy football speak for “the quarterback really likes throwing it to him. ”The downside? He started the season about as consistently as British weather—sunny one minute, pouring rain the next. Plus, he hasn’t sniffed a red zone target yet, so touchdown upside is limited. He’s the sort of player who might give you a respectable 8–10 points per game, and on a good day, a cheeky 15. Not bad for a chap who’s been warming benches in previous weeks.

Drake London has been catching more targets than a dart player on a pub crawl. In Week 3, he saw 8 looks from the quarterback, making him the clear leader in Atlanta’s passing game. His matchup against the Commanders is juicy—Washington has been as generous to wide receivers as a tea shop with free refills—and London might finally turn his target-heavy usage into actual points. The caveat? London’s production has been about as predictable as a London Tube strike. Despite all those looks, he hasn’t topped 60 yards in a game yet, and the Falcons’ love affair with the running game might limit him further. There’s also the small matter of quarterback uncertainty. Still, when he does click, London could provide a solid floor and the sort of ceiling that makes fantasy managers beam like they’ve just found a tenner in their jacket pocket.

Chase Brown has been getting the ball more than a confused postman, leading the NFL with a 77% rush share. On paper, this screams opportunity. Against Denver, there’s even a whiff of bounce-back potential.

But alas, Brown’s efficiency has been about as inspiring as a soggy crumpet. He posts the lowest success rate among starting backs (25.5%) and saw his snap share dip in Week 3, thanks to Samaje Perine and Tahj Brooks stealing some touches. Add the absence of Joe Burrow and a low team implied total, and suddenly that “volume equals fantasy points” mantra looks a bit shaky. He’s one of those players who could break out, or just break your heart. So, what’s the takeaway for Week 4? Hockenson might be the safe, steady tea—reliable but not flashy. London is the gamble, with the chance of a big score if the quarterback finally decides to cooperate. And Brown… well, Brown is the lottery ticket you hope pays off, but you wouldn’t be shocked if it didn’t. Fantasy football: it’s like a cup of tea—you can steep it wrong, but every once in a while, it’s perfect.

Hold up! Are you calling your call perfect, Sir Whittington? Because you are far from it! Anyway, KROG, it’s on you.

KROG’S Response:

For Week 4 in PPR formats, ranking these three players based on their projected usage, recent trends, matchup advantages, and overall floor/ceiling. All three face exploitable defenses, but Hockenson edges out as the top flex option due to his target share and a TE-friendly opponent. London follows with volume potential despite QB woes, while Brown slips to third amid a shaky backfield and tougher road spot. Projections assume standard PPR scoring (1 point per reception, 0.1 receiving yards, 6 receiving TDs). Choosing between these three for your lineup is a bit like picking the least wobbly grocery cart—you’ll make it work, but it won’t feel smooth.

TJ Hockenson enters Week 4 as the safest of the trio, and for good reason. He just put up 15.9 PPR points on a 25% target share with Carson Wentz at quarterback, and he draws a matchup against a Pittsburgh defense that has been nothing short of a godsend for tight ends. Since last season, twelve different TEs have scored double-digit PPR points against the Steelers. Through just three games this year, they’ve already allowed 17 catches, 211 yards, and three touchdowns on 23 targets. With Justin Jefferson pulling defenders away, Hockenson’s red-zone role is secure, tied for the team lead in targets last week. The setting adds another wrinkle, as this game will be played in Ireland, and the only thing scarier than Wentz in primetime might be Wentz adjusting to jet lag. Still, Hockenson’s role, health, and matchup keep him firmly in the TE1 mix with a projected 12.8 PPR points, the equivalent of a mid-range RB2 or WR4.

Drake London’s outlook is more volatile, but he remains a tempting WR3/flex option. The Falcons’ quarterback situation has been a carousel, and last week, Michael Penix Jr. completed only 70.7% of his passes deemed catchable, ranking near the bottom of the league. Despite that, London led the team in air yards with 89 and earned a hefty 24% first-read target share. The Commanders’ secondary has been prone to lapses, already allowing six touchdowns to wide receivers through three weeks. Their pass defense sits 20th in yards per attempt allowed, and Atlanta’s dome environment should only encourage passing volume if the Falcons fall behind. The quarterback’s inconsistency is a concern, of course. London’s 55% catch rate last week reflects that. But with at least eight targets in every game so far, he remains the centerpiece of Atlanta’s passing attack. The Falcons’ 0-3 start may push them toward conservative play-calling, yet London still projects for 11.2 PPR points. The situation feels a bit like watching a carnival ride: the quarterback spins one way, the offense lurches another, and somehow London still manages to walk away holding the teddy bear.

Chase Brown rounds out the trio, and unfortunately, he comes in with the rockiest path. The Bengals gave him a bell-cow role early—67% of the snaps, most of the carries—but his efficiency cratered in Week 3. Ten carries for three yards. Yes, you read that right. No, you don’t need new glasses. He salvaged the outing with four short catches, but it was still a day to forget. The matchup doesn’t do him many favors. Denver’s run defense ranks in the top ten in yards per carry allowed and has surrendered 50 or more rushing yards to running backs in only two of three games. Cincinnati’s Monday night trip to Denver adds fatigue to the mix, and with Samaje Perine and rookie Tahj Brooks getting sprinkled in last week, Brown’s grip on lead-back duties isn’t as secure as it once seemed. There is some hope. Brown has averaged over 18 touches in two of three games this year, and the Broncos have been generous to running backs in the passing game, allowing the second-most receptions to the position. With Jake Browning turning the ball over at alarming rates, Cincinnati may have no choice but to feed Brown as a short-yardage outlet. Still, his Week 3 efficiency leaves a bad taste, and his 9.4 projected PPR points slot him as more of a desperation flex play than a dependable starter.When weighing these three, Hockenson clearly sits at the top of the pile, London offers hope with volume despite his quarterback woes, and Brown is left clinging to passing-down usage in an ugly Bengals offense. None of them are perfect options, but if you’re deciding who gets the nod in your flex, trust the tight end with the Ireland spotlight, cross your fingers with London’s quarterback chaos, and hope Brown’s stat line looks a little less like a typo this time.

Tipp’s Response:

Even though I’m tied with Krog, and Sir Whittington is putting us to shame, it’s still a tight battle between man and machine. The players we are choosing from have really disappointed this season. Sure, it’s early, but come on,

Drake London looks poised to put on a show in Week 4! And no, it’s not entirely about a “Marcus Mariota revenge game” — well, maybe just a touch. The bigger story? The Falcons’ offense finally has a chance to thrive against a Washington defense that’s been surprisingly soft against wide receivers.  Atlanta needs to flush Week 3 down the toilet and get back on track. Don’t worry about London’s slow start this season. He’s been heavily involved, averaging nine targets per game — exactly the kind of volume you want when a player is underperforming. Volume is king in fantasy, and London is still very much in the conversation. The matchup this week is juicy. The Commanders have struggled against wideouts, and despite three games without a touchdown against Washington, London has a prime chance to break through. The Commanders’ embarrassment in Carolina last week only adds to the opportunity. When volume meets favorable matchups, fantasy points tend to follow.  Bottom Line: Drake London is a must-start in PPR leagues this week. High target volume plus a soft matchup sets him up for a big bounce-back performance. Don’t overthink it — the upside is undeniable.

T.J. Hockenson has clearly found a rhythm with Carson Wentz under center. Don’t expect gaudy yardage totals—Hockenson has never been a big-yardage tight end—but the red zone connection between these two is becoming undeniable. This week, Hockenson faces the league’s worst defense: the Pittsburgh Steelers. Let me say that again… the Steelers, who recently allowed Hunter Henry to look like Rob Gronkowski with two touchdowns. That should tell you everything you need to know about how generous they’ve been to tight ends lately. Expect Hockenson to find the end zone once more. His yardage might be modest, but in PPR and standard formats alike, it’s the touchdowns that make him a must-start this week.  Bottom Line: T.J. Hockenson isn’t a yardage monster, but his red zone role and matchup against Pittsburgh make him a high-upside play in Week 4. Expect a touchdown, even if the rest of the stat line is underwhelming.

Chase Brown entered the season with plenty of hype, but a nagging toe injury and the absence of Joe Burrow have limited his production so far. His bread and butter—pass-catching—has yet to appear, with under 20 receiving yards across the first three games. The silver lining? Brown is still seeing 18.3 touches per game, and Week 4 presents a plus matchup against a defense that has struggled against running backs. In theory, this should be an opportunity for him to thrive. The catch: the Bengals’ offense has been stale without Burrow. Even with volume and a favorable matchup, efficiency is lacking, and big fantasy outputs are harder to come by until the offense gets moving again. Bottom Line: Brown has the volume and a friendly matchup on his side, but the Bengals’ sputtering offense without Burrow caps his upside. Expect steady touches, but don’t count on a breakout until the offense regains its rhythm.

Week 4 Picks

Sir Whittington

  1. T.J. Hockenson
  2. Drake London
  3. Chase Brown

Krog

  1. T.J. Hockenson
  2. Drake London
  3. Chase Brown

Tipp

  1. Drake London
  2. T.J. Hockenson
  3. Chase Brown